The short answer
A zipper gives a closer, flatter waist and works in almost any woven fabric, at the cost of one more step to sew. An elastic waist is faster and more forgiving, but it needs an opening wide enough to pass over your hips, and it changes the numbers you cut from. Neither is better; they suit different fabrics and different wearers.
What actually changes in the cut
Everything about the closure comes down to one question: how does the skirt get past your hips?
With a zip, the answer is the opening. The skirt is cut to a waist opening that stays close to your body, and the zip (or buttons, or a placket) opens enough for you to get in and out. The waist radius is based on your body waist plus wearing ease — typically 0–2 cm for a fitted skirt.
With elastic, the answer is stretch. The skirt has no opening, so the finished waist opening has to be large enough to pull over your hips. That means cutting the waist opening wider than your body waist before the elastic gathers it in. A common way to size it is to take the larger of your hip measurement and your waist and add about 5 cm so the opening can pass over your hips when you pull the skirt on, then cut to that. Those 5 cm are wearing ease, not seam allowance: seam allowance and the turn-in for the casing are separate numbers, and the calculator asks for them on their own. If you do not know your hips, waist plus about 31 cm is a rough substitute — but measure your hips, because it is the number that decides whether you can get dressed.
Can your elastic actually stretch that far?
A wider opening only works if the elastic can stretch to match. Cut the elastic to waist × 0.90 + 2.5 cm for standard elastic; firm or wide elastic can be cut longer (× 0.95), soft or thin elastic shorter (× 0.85). The extra 2.5 cm is not band you end up wearing: it is the overlap you sew when you join the elastic into a loop, so the finished loop is shorter than the length you cut.
So do the arithmetic on the loop, not on the cut length. A 70 cm waist gives a cut length of 70 × 0.90 + 2.5 = 65.5 cm; overlap the ends by 2.5 cm to join the loop and the finished loop is 63 cm.
The figure used here — that elastic reaches 1.5 × its own length, a 50% stretch — is a working assumption for the arithmetic, not a fact about your elastic. Real elastic varies enormously. On that assumption a 63 cm loop reaches about 94.5 cm. With 92 cm hips that is a 46% stretch: comfortably inside the assumption, so the skirt pulls on. With 110 cm hips it needs about a 75% stretch — well past it, and the waist will feel tight every time you put the skirt on. That is the point where you go to wider or firmer elastic, or to a zip.
This is the same test, on the same figure, that the calculator runs: whether the finished elastic loop, stretched by 50%, reaches your hip measurement. Here the loop reaches 94.5 cm, so any hip measurement above that comes back flagged as too short.
Test your actual elastic by stretching a measured piece against a ruler before you cut it, and use what your elastic gives in place of the 50% figure. A soft 2 cm elastic from one shop can behave nothing like the 4 cm one from another.
The calculator runs this check for you when you choose the elastic closure and enter your hips; it reports whether the finished elastic loop reaches your hip measurement at an assumed 50% stretch.
Sewing the two closures
Invisible zip in the side seam or centre back: finish the seam first, then insert the zip so the pull disappears under the seam allowance. On a circle skirt, put it in a side seam if the skirt has one, and be aware the bias in that seam will want to stretch — stay-stitch the seam line before you fit the zip.
Exposed zip: easier to get right on a first attempt, and easier to shorten later.
Elastic casing: fold the top edge over by the width of the elastic plus 1 cm, stitch, thread the elastic, then secure it at the side seams with a few stitches so it cannot roll. Or sew the elastic straight onto the top edge, stretching it as you stitch — quicker, but the gathers are more even with a casing.
Which one for which fabric
- Structured cotton, linen, wool, corduroy: a zip is worth the effort; these fabrics can hold a crisp waistband.
- Thin viscose, crepe, chiffon: elastic is usually kinder, because it gathers rather than fighting the drape.
- Anything with a directional print: plan the print before you cut — lay every panel the same way up, and choose where the seam will fall so the interruption in the repeat lands where it is least conspicuous. The gathered top edge works in your favour here, so treat it as part of the plan rather than something to ignore.
- A skirt you will wear over jeans and tights: elastic is more forgiving when your waist measurement changes.
- A very full circle in heavy fabric: whether elastic holds depends on how heavy the skirt is, how wide the elastic is, and how it is attached. A narrow elastic stitched straight onto the edge will let a heavy full circle sag; a wide one in a proper casing, or two rows of stitching, copes far better. When the skirt is heavy enough that you are not sure it will hold, that is where a zip and a fitted waistband earn their keep.
A waistband changes the numbers
A separate waistband is cut as a straight strip, not as an arc: length = waist + 2 × seam allowance + overlap, width = 2 × finished band width + 2 × seam allowance. Basing the skirt radius on body waist is right, but only when the band has a closure; a band with no opening has to be sized from the wider pull-on figure, exactly like the elastic casing.
What to decide first
Choose the closure before you cut fabric, because it decides the waist radius. Then the sweep, then the length. If you are still working out the radii, the formula page has the arithmetic, and the hemming guide covers the last step after the waist is done.
Ask about your own skirt